Query:

Because of the general duty to love our neighbors, I think that as a matter of public policy there must be rights to have certain goods -- in one sense of the term, "positive" rights.  What do you think?

 

 

Some people, like the late John Rawls, say that we should set aside our religious and philosophical disagreements – our “comprehensive doctrines,” he calls them -- for the sake of practical agreement.  Others say that we can’t do that, and that it’s futile to try.

Can we, or can’t we?  It depends on what you mean.